Orcworm's SMP Server

We have moved to http://www.orcworm.co.uk

Join the forum, it's quick and easy

Orcworm's SMP Server

We have moved to http://www.orcworm.co.uk

Orcworm's SMP Server

Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Forum dedicated to Orcworm's Minecraft SMP Server, located at: orcworm.co.uk


+12
filmjolk
Cagu
Xltimus
whitejack
Orcworm
Baldymoint7
paradox74
Ciphon
Hamosh86
Grintendo
FillerB
Gornemant
16 posters

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Poll

    No building atop someone else's creation

    [ 0 ]
    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Bar_left0%Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Bar_right [0%] 
    [ 8 ]
    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Bar_left17%Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Bar_right [17%] 
    [ 34 ]
    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Bar_left74%Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Bar_right [74%] 
    [ 4 ]
    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Bar_left9%Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Bar_right [9%] 

    Total Votes: 46
    Gornemant
    Gornemant
    Gornemant
    Donator
    Donator


    Posts : 190
    Join date : 2011-01-13
    • Post n°1

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Gornemant 2011-05-23, 19:58

    As we are not allowed to post in ban appeals, I would like to discuss this in here instead, for all to voice their opinion.
    I would prefer if you keep your flaming, spamming, drama, trolling, complaints and ban issues out of this topic. I would like the forum staff to remove said posts when they do happen before the discussion ends as well, if possible.


    I am not opening this discussion to troll or light up drama that is already in progress, I just think that this rules should also clearly apply to any above ground player construction (as in clearly visible, like houses etc..) and fenced areas and not just bigger towns. I would personally hate to see someone starting to build yet another sky city or any other kind of random platform above my fenced area and house, as I would consider this a dick/grief move not any different from a certain griefer group (the cobblecloud on spacemonkey, if that rings a bell to you).
    I did not include any underground structures, as you can't see them or know they are there unless you clearly mark them above ground.


    Quote by Jarvisd that I wanted to comment on, irrelevant (ban appeal) information has been removed. ( [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] )
    Jarvisd wrote:In my opinion building over some city which is about to be zoned is griefing. I mean, I can't go and build my house above grintendos shop? Razz That is my logic and we will see where it goes in appeal.

    Thoughts, opinion? Smile
    • Back to top
    FillerB
    FillerB
    FillerB
    So long and thanks for all the fish!


    Posts : 4066
    Join date : 2011-01-30
    Age : 36
    Location : Netherlands
    • Post n°2

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by FillerB 2011-05-23, 20:04

    "All of the above and non-fenced houses (or obvious player constructions)"

    There is PLENTY of space left on the map so people can go bugger off to another, uninhabited, area if they feel the need to make a godawful floating construction.
    This ALSO means Rune-waypoints-over-houses. I don't know which Staff authorized that but you are a stupid asshole.
    • Back to top
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    In-Game Staff
    In-Game Staff


    Posts : 1942
    Join date : 2011-03-05
    Age : 93
    Location : England
    • Post n°3

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Grintendo 2011-05-23, 20:17

    "All of the above and non-fenced houses (or obvious player constructions)"

    100%
    • Back to top
    Hamosh86
    Hamosh86
    Hamosh86


    Posts : 276
    Join date : 2011-04-09
    Age : 29
    Location : Stalkers!
    • Post n°4

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Hamosh86 2011-05-23, 20:28

    ya 4/4 votes go to the right one
    • Back to top
    Ciphon
    Ciphon
    Ciphon


    Posts : 1637
    Join date : 2011-03-06
    Age : 27
    Location : 156,68,1261
    • Post n°5

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Ciphon 2011-05-24, 00:31

    some idiot at the spawn built that giant ugly wooden structure thing over my "dont build in this area please" zone, yet you dont here me complaining, but still i think that sounds about right not to be allowed to build over someone elses house, cause what if they were planning to expand it upwards, but now they can't?
    • Back to top
    paradox74
    paradox74
    paradox74


    Posts : 592
    Join date : 2011-01-07
    Location : h3ll
    • Post n°6

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by paradox74 2011-05-24, 01:18

    I personally have a small humble house on the ground and am quite happy with it, but If some asshole were to build their "sky city" above my house thus blocking the sun and making mobs spawn by my house during the day, I would be mad. Also I live in a secluded area and I would hate to see a house right above mine when there is plenty of open room all around me.
    • Back to top
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    In-Game Staff
    In-Game Staff


    Posts : 1942
    Join date : 2011-03-05
    Age : 93
    Location : England
    • Post n°7

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Grintendo 2011-05-24, 01:24

    Extending on from this, the huge "sky city" just outside the spawn gate, seriously? Can we take some action on that since...

    1) It's fugly
    2) Spawns mobs
    3) They keep extending
    4) Soon the whole spawn area will be covered in darkness...
    • Back to top
    paradox74
    paradox74
    paradox74


    Posts : 592
    Join date : 2011-01-07
    Location : h3ll
    • Post n°8

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by paradox74 2011-05-24, 01:34

    Grintendo wrote:Extending on from this, the huge "sky city" just outside the spawn gate, seriously? Can we take some action on that since...

    1) It's fugly
    2) Spawns mobs
    3) They keep extending
    4) Soon the whole spawn area will be covered in darkness...
    More or less exacty what I was talking about. Hopefully in 1.6 we can change the rules to fix this.
    • Back to top
    Gornemant
    Gornemant
    Gornemant
    Donator
    Donator


    Posts : 190
    Join date : 2011-01-13
    • Post n°9

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Gornemant 2011-05-24, 02:01

    Grintendo wrote:Extending on from this, the huge "sky city" just outside the spawn gate, seriously? Can we take some action on that since...

    1) It's fugly
    2) Spawns mobs
    3) They keep extending
    4) Soon the whole spawn area will be covered in darkness...
    My thoughts exactly.
    Devilsfan65 claims that it's his land, though even though he has a zone there, it is not 50 by 50 like he claims it to be, and he build far beyond his zone and over other people's work as well, not to mention that he builds right above the exit stairs.
    • Back to top
    Baldymoint7
    Baldymoint7
    Baldymoint7


    Posts : 1162
    Join date : 2011-01-24
    Age : 26
    Location : CANADA!!!! RAWR!!!
    • Post n°10

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Baldymoint7 2011-05-24, 02:26

    I also agree with Filler I mean theres still a shitload of space leaft on the map,
    we just wiped it like what 2months ago? Some people are just douchs trying to
    make you angry. If i had this happen to me I'd be pissed but then again my treehouse
    is like on the brink of the top of the map...
    • Back to top
    FillerB
    FillerB
    FillerB
    So long and thanks for all the fish!


    Posts : 4066
    Join date : 2011-01-30
    Age : 36
    Location : Netherlands
    • Post n°11

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by FillerB 2011-05-24, 07:00

    I PMed the owner of that Skymonstrosity (and made a sign in front of what I think his main entrance is).
    He has until Saturday to remove all excessive bits of it (anything not in his zone that is over the paths/other houses) or I will do it for him.


    Seriously what do people find so entertaining about those floating pieces of crap? If you're gonna make something like that at least have the decency to make it small and not look like shit.
    • Back to top
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    In-Game Staff
    In-Game Staff


    Posts : 1942
    Join date : 2011-03-05
    Age : 93
    Location : England
    • Post n°12

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Grintendo 2011-05-24, 07:53

    Cheers Filler, i didn't realised it's zoned? That's worse than me zoning my plot outside the spawn...
    • Back to top
    FillerB
    FillerB
    FillerB
    So long and thanks for all the fish!


    Posts : 4066
    Join date : 2011-01-30
    Age : 36
    Location : Netherlands
    • Post n°13

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by FillerB 2011-05-24, 07:56

    Only like a quarter of the thing is actually zoned.
    • Back to top
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    In-Game Staff
    In-Game Staff


    Posts : 1942
    Join date : 2011-03-05
    Age : 93
    Location : England
    • Post n°14

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Grintendo 2011-05-29, 03:18

    Just looked at it now, it's even further extended, the stairs is rapidly loosing light...

    Necro'd: Wondering if any progress is been made/planned?
    • Back to top
    Orcworm
    Orcworm
    Orcworm
    Owner
    Owner


    Posts : 5936
    Join date : 2010-10-31
    Age : 30
    Location : England
    • Post n°15

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Orcworm 2011-05-29, 03:21

    I'm gonna' move it when I have time, probably when this attack crap is over with.
    • Back to top
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    In-Game Staff
    In-Game Staff


    Posts : 1942
    Join date : 2011-03-05
    Age : 93
    Location : England
    • Post n°16

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Grintendo 2011-05-29, 03:23

    Awesome, cheers Smile
    • Back to top
    whitejack
    whitejack
    whitejack


    Posts : 1
    Join date : 2011-05-29
    Age : 30
    Location : Pennsylvania
    • Post n°17

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by whitejack 2011-05-29, 03:35

    Hello. I helped make the sky platform with devilsfan, i did not intend to grief people. The reason why it is floating is we are trying to farm trees and sell them and a sky platform seemed to be the best way to protect the trees from other players. Tt will be moved when the server comes back up. again we are sorry for all the trouble.
    • Back to top
    Xltimus
    Xltimus
    Xltimus
    Member
    Member


    Posts : 239
    Join date : 2010-11-26
    Age : 31
    Location : United States
    • Post n°18

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Xltimus 2011-05-30, 05:58

    Building above someone's 'work' without their permission, in my opinion is griefing. Unless of course its a multi-leveled city or something.

    Grintendo wrote:Extending on from this, the huge "sky city" just outside the spawn gate, seriously? Can we take some action on that since...

    1) It's fugly
    2) Spawns mobs
    3) They keep extending
    4) Soon the whole spawn area will be covered in darkness...

    A) A lot of them are pretty much flat squares made out of dirt. I would personally like to see one thats considered... Breathtaking? Floating ruins/Ancient Civilization type deal maybe?
    B) Squares are easy to extend, a planned layout is a bit different,
    C) If they built these things over lakes and oceans, that solves quite a bit of the problem.
    • Back to top
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    In-Game Staff
    In-Game Staff


    Posts : 1942
    Join date : 2011-03-05
    Age : 93
    Location : England
    • Post n°19

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Grintendo 2011-05-30, 06:22

    whitejack wrote:Hello. I helped make the sky platform with devilsfan, i did not intend to grief people. The reason why it is floating is we are trying to farm trees and sell them and a sky platform seemed to be the best way to protect the trees from other players. Tt will be moved when the server comes back up. again we are sorry for all the trouble.

    Don't worry you haven't griefed as such. Your building is just unwanted really, you didn't build over people apart from the spawn, it's just that things like that in that area are a bad idea. Not grief though, don't worry about that.
    • Back to top
    Cagu
    Cagu
    Cagu


    Posts : 62
    Join date : 2011-04-23
    • Post n°20

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Cagu 2011-05-30, 10:09

    Hey my base is a floating island! Though I built it over a lake and a decent few minutes away from the spawn and it as existed for months now. It's not complete but when it's done I'll throw a house party.
    • Back to top
    filmjolk
    avatar
    filmjolk
    In-Game Staff
    In-Game Staff


    Posts : 114
    Join date : 2010-12-07
    Age : 35
    Location : Sweden
    • Post n°21

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by filmjolk 2011-06-01, 21:04

    Someone built a spawn town ontop of the minecart station in spawn!

    what about ppl building under you? What you cant see cant hurt you? "My view is ruined!!!!" Get over it, what about your future basement? oh wait! you cant, cause someone pulled an underground highway b(e)low your house.

    Ofcourse its easier to tell if something is above your buildings (above ground), but in my opinion, what lies below is far more important. But then again, minecraft is, for a lot of ppl, about the aesthetic value.
    • Back to top
    menaceofri
    menaceofri
    menaceofri


    Posts : 174
    Join date : 2011-05-31
    Age : 38
    Location : Goldsboro, NC
    • Post n°22

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by menaceofri 2011-06-02, 04:44

    haha yes, down with sky monstrosity's! I agree with whomever it was that said it first, building above/below someones land intentionally is trespassing you limit that persons creative talents by limiting them from expanding their vision upwards or downwards, its a different story if you dont know its there, otherwise find your own plot of ground to stake your claim on the world. A common rule that I LOVE and think every server should include would be something like, No buildings that are excessively impractical. Creative 2.0 is fine, but towns floating on a whim are just meh, so ugly and ruins the land under themaswell. I build a sky village once, and then i supported it with iron colums, and X-braces. obviously i voted NO building on other peoples land. and sorry for posting in the original ban appeal at first.
    • Back to top
    killerdonkey1
    killerdonkey1
    killerdonkey1


    Posts : 43
    Join date : 2011-04-29
    Age : 26
    Location : Corstophine Edinburgh Scotland
    • Post n°23

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by killerdonkey1 2011-06-02, 04:51

    Hey cagu can I come too house party Very Happy
    • Back to top
    shades
    shades
    shades
    Member
    Member


    Posts : 52
    Join date : 2010-12-04
    • Post n°24

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by shades 2011-06-02, 22:56

    So what your not aloud to build underground?
    • Back to top
    Albuca
    Albuca
    Albuca
    In-Game Staff
    In-Game Staff


    Posts : 1205
    Join date : 2011-02-18
    Age : 32
    Location : 192.168.1.109
    • Post n°25

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Albuca 2011-06-02, 23:03

    shades wrote:So what your not aloud to build underground?
    ...
    [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
    • Back to top
    shades
    shades
    shades
    Member
    Member


    Posts : 52
    Join date : 2010-12-04
    • Post n°26

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by shades 2011-06-02, 23:04

    wtf ? i just asked a question.
    • Back to top
    shades
    shades
    shades
    Member
    Member


    Posts : 52
    Join date : 2010-12-04
    • Post n°27

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by shades 2011-06-02, 23:05

    yeah my bad i read wrong.. ;l dont cry about it ok
    • Back to top
    Orcworm
    Orcworm
    Orcworm
    Owner
    Owner


    Posts : 5936
    Join date : 2010-10-31
    Age : 30
    Location : England
    • Post n°28

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Orcworm 2011-06-02, 23:07

    Take your attitude elsewhere shades.
    • Back to top
    shades
    shades
    shades
    Member
    Member


    Posts : 52
    Join date : 2010-12-04
    • Post n°29

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by shades 2011-06-02, 23:08

    Yes sirr just in shitty mood. dont mean to take it out on peepz.
    • Back to top
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    Grintendo
    In-Game Staff
    In-Game Staff


    Posts : 1942
    Join date : 2011-03-05
    Age : 93
    Location : England
    • Post n°30

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Grintendo 2011-06-03, 00:48

    Avoid double posts as well...
    • Back to top
    Sponsored content

    Sponsored content


    • Post n°31

    Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No Empty Re: Building above someone else = griefing? Yes/No

    Post by Sponsored content

    • Back to top
      Current date/time is 2024-11-24, 20:21